Market
Market
Muskoka Cottage Market Q3 2026: Buyers Gain More Ground
MUSKOKA COTTAGE MARKET · Q3 2026 REPORT
Q3 2026: A Market Leaning Further Toward Buyers
Ten years of Q3 history, nine months of 2026, and a supply glut that kept building
The Muskoka cottage market right now is a supply story, not a demand story. Buyers are still closing deals at close to last year's pace. But Sellers keep showing up faster than buyers can absorb them, and a rising share of those sellers are giving up rather than negotiating. That imbalance is what's actually driving this market, and Q3 pushed it further than Q2 did, not less. As I write this there are almost 500 waterfront cottages for sale in Muskoka. That's an astounding listing number for the end of September.
Numbers in a Nutshell
Active Inventory & Months of Supply
12-month rolling averages, 10-year trend through September 2026
Months of supply tells us how long it would take to sell everything currently on the market at the current pace of sales. Six months is the textbook line between a buyer's market and a seller's market. The trailing 12-month average is sitting at 11.5 months right now, up 23% from a year ago and well above that balanced-market line, while active inventory itself is up nearly 13%. Both lines point the same direction as our terminations and sale volume charts: this is a market with considerably more supply than demand can currently absorb. August and September 2026 (the dashed amber segment) are not yet reported by the board. We estimated them by applying the average year over year change from May through July 2026 to last year's August and September totals. We will swap in the confirmed figures and update this chart as soon as the board publishes them.
Supply
Supply keeps outrunning demand
New listings are up 17.1% year over year and running nearly 30% above the 8-year Q3 norm. Active inventory is up 10.4% year over year and two thirds above normal, and months of supply, shown above, sits at 8.0, 78% above the 8-year Q3 average of 4.5. The sales-to-new-listings ratio, the share of fresh listings that actually find a buyer, fell to 41% from 49% a year ago, well below the 8-year average of 63%.
The terminations chart above is the clearest read on where that imbalance ends up. Sellers aren't disappearing, they're giving up. Q3 terminations came to roughly 188, up 46.6% from Q3 2025's already-record 128, and more than eight times our 8-year Q3 average of 23. OnePoint, one of the boards feeding into that total, already shows 93 terminations recorded from August 1 through September 21 on its own, a real and current number pointing the same direction, though it's a partial count on a single board that's still growing.
Sale Volume: 12-Month Rolling Average
Monthly sales, trailing 12-month average, 10-year trend through September 2026
Sale volume is holding roughly steady, the trailing 12-month average is down just 2.7% from a year ago, a much calmer picture than the terminations trend we published alongside this chart. Read together, the two tell a consistent story: buyers are still closing deals at close to last year's pace, but sellers are cancelling more listings rather than waiting them out, which is the signature of a market with more supply than demand rather than one that is falling apart. August and September 2026 (the dashed amber segment) are not yet reported by the combined-board data this chart otherwise uses. We estimated them by applying the average year over year change from May through July 2026 (roughly flat) to last year's August and September totals. Separately, we can already see 26 August closings and 4 September closings (through Sep 10) on the OnePoint board alone, one of the boards that feeds into the combined total. We're not using that figure to adjust the estimate above: OnePoint's own past-month counts kept growing every time we re-pulled them, which tells us member offices are still entering recent sales, so today's OnePoint snapshot understates even OnePoint's own eventual total, and we don't yet know by how much. We'll swap in the confirmed combined-board figures and update this chart as soon as they're published.
Listing Terminations: 12-Month Rolling Average
Monthly terminations volume, trailing 12-month average, 10-year trend through September 2026
We track terminations, listings that were cancelled rather than sold or expired, on a trailing 12-month basis because the raw monthly counts are too seasonal and too small on their own to read cleanly. A rising trend here is one of the earliest signals of seller frustration in a softening market, and the current run is the highest in the 10 years we have on file. August and September 2026 (the dashed amber segment) are not yet reported by the combined-board data this chart otherwise uses. We estimated them by applying the average year over year growth rate from May through July 2026 (about +38%) to last year's August and September totals. Separately, OnePoint (one of the boards that feeds into the combined total) already shows 93 terminations from Aug 1 through Sep 21. We're not converting that into a combined-board estimate: unlike sale volume, we don't have a track record comparing OnePoint's termination counts against the confirmed combined-board totals, so we don't know what share of the true figure 93 represents, and OnePoint's own past-month counts have consistently kept growing on re-pull, meaning today's number understates OnePoint's own eventual total too. We'll swap in the confirmed combined-board figures and update this chart as soon as they're published.
Demand
Demand held, almost
Set against that supply picture, demand looks almost unremarkable, which is itself the point. Sale volume came to roughly 196 for the quarter, down just 3.0% from Q3 2025's 202. Buyers didn't retreat. They just didn't need to chase anything, with 505 active listings on average to choose from against 202 or fewer buyers actually closing. Average price is up 4.2% year over year to $1.76M and median price is up 12.6% to $1.20M, both comfortably above their 8-year Q3 norms. But the sale-to-list price ratio slipped slightly to 94.3%, and the average listing is now sitting 54 days on market, up from 52 a year ago. Sellers aren't cutting prices dramatically. They're accepting slightly bigger discounts and waiting longer, which is what a market looks like when supply has the upper hand without prices actually correcting.
The Numbers
Q3 2026 against Q3 2025 and eight years of Q3 history
The 8-year average runs 2018 through 2025; we exclude 2016 and 2017, where multi-board historical coverage is incomplete, the same convention we've used in every report since we started publishing terminations data.
| Metric | Q3 2026 | Q3 2025 | YoY | 8-yr Q3 avg | vs. 8-yr |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sale volume | 196 | 202 | −3.0% | 237 | −17.3% |
| Terminations | 188 | 128 | +46.6% | 23 | +720% |
| New listings | 488 | 417 | +17.1% | 378 | +29.3% |
| Active listings (avg) | 505 | 457 | +10.4% | 302 | +67.4% |
| Months of supply | 8.0 | 6.9 | +16.2% | 4.5 | +77.1% |
| Sales-to-new-listings ratio | 41% | 49% | −16.4% | 63% | −35.9% |
| Average price | $1.76M | $1.69M | +4.2% | $1.50M | +17.2% |
| Median price | $1.20M | $1.06M | +12.6% | $993K | +20.6% |
| Sale-to-list price ratio | 94.3% | 94.5% | −0.2% | 96.7% | −2.5% |
| Avg days on market | 54 | 52 | +3.7% | 52 | +4.2% |
Early, partial reads from OnePoint alone (not yet reflected above): 26 sale closings in August, 4 through September 10, and 93 terminations from August 1 through September 21.
Year to Date
Nine months in, 2026 looks softer than Q3 alone suggests
Q3 on its own was close to flat on sales. The first nine months of the year are not. Year-to-date sale volume sits at 348, down a modest 1.4% from last year's 353 but down 27.2% from the 8-year YTD average of 478, a much larger gap than Q3 shows by itself, because January through April was unusually slow and Q3's near-flat showing hasn't closed that gap. Terminations YTD stand at 293, up 24.5% from last year and running at roughly 6.5 times the 8-year YTD norm. Months of supply YTD averages 11.9, more than double the 8-year norm of 5.6. Median price YTD is actually down 6.5% from last year, to $1.20M from $1.29M, the one figure in this report where the year-over-year direction and the historical-average direction point the same way, both down, even though it's still 16.6% above the 8-year YTD norm in absolute terms.
The luxury pullback
Only 15 cottages have sold for more than $3 million so far in Q3, against 27 over the same stretch last year, a real pullback at the very top of the market. We'd read that with some caution though: a meaningful share of listings above $3 million sell off-market through private, unlisted transactions, so this comparison reflects what's closed through the public board data, not necessarily the full luxury market.
What This Means
What this means right now
If you are buying
This is still a buyer's market, and it's leaning further that way than it was last quarter, not less. Inventory is running two thirds above normal, less than half of new listings find a buyer, and sellers are increasingly walking away rather than negotiating. You have more room and more time than you did a year ago.
If you are selling
The gap between listing and selling has widened since last quarter. Pricing to today's market, not to 2022 or even to last year, is still the only strategy that consistently works. The alternative, shown clearly above, is joining the growing pile of listings that come off the market having never sold at all.
Checking Our Work
What we got right, and wrong, last quarter
Last quarter we called three things. We said the termination cycle had peaked. It hadn't, the rolling average kept climbing every month since. We said months of supply was improving as spring buyers returned. That held, it kept falling seasonally, but it's improving against a worse year-over-year base than last time, still up 16% from Q3 2025. And we said sales were flat, not falling, year over year. That held for Q2, then flipped to a small decline in Q3. One call wrong, one right with a caveat, one that held until it didn't. We'd rather report that plainly than quietly reset the scorecard each quarter.
Questions on any of this? Give us a call.
Contact Us
