Otter Lake Cottages for Sale

Otter Lake

Otter Lake is located just outside of Parry Sound between Lake Joseph and Georgian Bay. The crystal-clear waters and stunning sunsets make it the perfect location for swimming, fishing, boating, and other water activities. The lake is known for its excellent fishing, with anglers coming from all over to catch smallmouth bass, northern pike, and walleye. It's also very close to hiking trails and  Oastler Lake park making it a haven for nature enthusiasts.

Big & Little Otter lakes are considered medium-sized.  Combined they have 38 kms of shoreline with medium cottage density and just over 500 cottages. Both the CNR & CP rail lines go past Otter, one by the narrows and one at the north end. The “Long Arm” is a long bay to the west & “Little Long Arm” protrudes to the east. about 2 hours drive from Toronto.


Quick Lake Facts

  • Originally named  Nis-ge-gu-bing
  • Large lake @ over 500 hectares with 38 kms of shoreline.
  • water level is maintained by an MNR owned and operated dam.
  • 5% of the shoreline is Crown land
  • Year round cottages generally $900,000-$1,600,000++

Real Estate Snapshot

2019 - 6 Sold $322,000 - $1,617,500 | Median $735,000

2020 - 13 Sold $292,000 - $1,075,000 | Median $542,425

2021 - 16 Sold $530,000 - $1,795,000 | Median $1,109,000

2022 - 10 Sold $322,000 - $1617,500 | Median $918,750

* Freehold properties - The Lakelands Association of Realtors®

Current Otter Lake Real Estate Listings

finding your muskoka logo
Looking at cottages for sale in Muskoka? Reach out and let us know what you're looking for!